Copyright © 2003 by The Voice of Prophecy
David B. Smith

P.O. Box 53055    
Los Angeles, CA 90053   

Listen to Real Audio Broadcast
October 15, 2003
THE HOTLINE TO HELL #3

“CAN I HAVE A ‘DO-OVER’?”

In some forms of “rapture” theology, if you miss the last trolley out of planet earth, there will be ANOTHER last trolley out later. But this parable by Jesus, “The Rich Man and Lazarus,” seems to suggest that on the other side of death, there ARE no second chances.

In his wonderfully entertaining baseball book, The Umpire Strikes Back, the late Ron Luciano tells a story that goes against everything they teach you in the Al Somers Umpire Instructional Course. Right or wrong, you’ve got to make a call. Get in position, get a good look, get help from your fellow crew members if you have to . . . but make a call. And of course, in his colorful career as an American League ump, Luciano had his share of heart-stopping, eyelash calls, including a famous one in the ALCS between the Yankees and Royals back in 1978, Game Three, where he had to call out Lou Piniella on a bang-bang tag play at the plate by Kansas City catcher Darrell Porter. Yankee Stadium just exploded in rage, all directed at him, and he describes it as the worst five minutes in his career.

Well, back in the 1950s, down in the old Pioneer League, there was once a game where the legendary George Sosniak was behind home plate. There was a baserunner on third with just one out, and the hitter lifted a fly ball to medium-deep left field. This being sacrifice-fly time, the guy on third poised himself to dash for home the second the ball hit the fielder’s mitt. The catch was made, he took off for home, the outfielder uncorked a perfect one-hop throw to the catcher covering the plate, and he applied the tag. And I mean, this was as razor-close as you could get. The ball and the runner and the tag and the dust all seemed to arrive at the very same microsecond.

And there was this long pause while umpire Sosniak just looked at the play with an inscrutable look on his face. The baserunner waited. The catcher waited. The scorekeeper waited. Both managers waited. The fans in the stands waited. The radio audience waited. Everybody waited because the ump wasn’t extending his thumb for out or putting both hands out, palms down, for safe.

Finally the catcher said the one word that was on the lips of everybody: “WELL?!!”

And the ump, in a thin, not very authoritarian voice, said rather weakly: “I don’t know. It was just so close . . . I don’t know what to call.”

And believe it or not, after a couple of very strange minutes of discussion, both teams actually agreed to a “do-over.” The runner went back to third, the left fielder went back to the approximate spot where he caught the ball the first time, the catcher got behind the plate, and the ump gave a signal. When he said “go,” the runner started for home, the fielder threw the ball in again, the catcher tagged the runner, and he was out by a good five feet. True story.

You may recall in the old cowboy film, City Slickers, how Billy Crystal and his friends wish aloud that life could have do-overs. That after a colossal mess-up like a bad marriage, or getting arrested, or just plain having your whole life turn out bad, you could raise your hand and ask for it: “I want a do-over.” And get it.

Of course, friend, in the Christian faith, a do-over is exactly what the struggling man or woman of God DOES get. When we’re forgiven, our bad batting averages and our skyrocketing earned run averages are recalibrated. We get to start over with a fresh slate.

However, there’s an important stipulation to this privilege, and that’s exactly where we are in this parable, or story, by Jesus entitled “The Rich Man and Lazarus.” You can have a do-over. You can get forgiveness. But there does come a time at the end of the season where the 162 games have been played, and now you move to the World Series. And in October, when it really counts, there are no do-overs. There’s no second chance if you haven’t qualified for postseason play by then.

Let’s resume our story here in Luke 16, and remember that there was a wealthy, selfish man who lived in careless, snobbish luxury while ignoring a poor beggar named Lazarus who parked himself just outside the rich guy’s front gate next to the limousine and the Jacuzzi. And when they both died, there was a reversal of fortunes: the beggar covered with sores . . . soared right to Paradise and reclined in the bosom of Abraham. While the rich man, with his hot stock deals, went to a place that was hotter yet. You get the picture.

Now, even down in the nether regions, this formerly wealthy sinner thinks the same social order is in operation. So he calls up to Father Abraham — in the parable heaven and hell are just across the street from each other — “Please send Lazarus over here for two seconds so that he can bring me a drink of water.” Even just a drop of water for his tongue, he begs, but he kind of expects that a wretch like Lazarus can still be bossed around. One of the lessons of this story is that the roles of this life might be reversed during eternity, but the rich man hasn’t learned that. But now in verses 25 and 26 Father Abraham — popular Jewish literature sometimes pictured him as operating the Welcome Center to heaven, much as Christians share anecdotes where St. Peter supposedly does the honors — Father Abraham rejects the rich man’s request . . . and let’s notice why:

“But Abraham replied, ‘Son, remember that in your lifetime you received your good things, while Lazarus received bad things, but now he is comforted here and you are in agony.”
But now, pay attention to this, in regards to “do-overs”:
“And besides all this,” Father Abraham informs him through the heaven-to-hell hotline, “between us and you a great chasm has been fixed, so that those who want to go from here to you CANNOT, nor can anyone cross over from there to us.’”

You know, it’s an important principle of Bible study that parables are designed, really, to teach just one key concept. Some of the other peripheral details might or might not have significance, but we have to focus on that one important Bible truth. And friend, I honestly do not think that Jesus Christ was trying to teach His followers anything significant about how far apart in the universe heaven and hell are, or if people can talk and visit back and forth. I don’t think that’s the point. Instead, the crucial lesson is this: once a believer, or a non-believer, has gone to their destination at the end of time, that destiny is fixed. There are no do-overs. No second chances. No tomorrows where you can move from hell up to heaven.

Now, the rich man wasn’t asking for heaven here, just a drop of cool water. But let’s finish the story as Jesus is telling it here in Luke 16. After Father Abraham says no, Lazarus can’t make this mission trip to the Southland, the chasm in the road is just too wide, the rich man has a second request.

“He answered, ‘Then I beg you, father, send Lazarus to my father’s house, for I have five brothers. Let him warn them, so that they will not also come to this place of torment.’ Abraham replied, ‘They have Moses and the Prophets; let them listen to them.’ ‘No, father Abraham,’ he said, ‘but if someone from the dead goes to them, they will repent.’ He said to him, ‘If they do not listen to Moses and the Prophets, they will not be convinced even if someone rises from the dead.’”

Now, friend, let’s digest what Christ is teaching here. First of all, we have just this one life where we must choose heaven and the mindset of heaven. Once a person dies — as the two main characters in this story did — or once we see Christ, the righteous Judge, coming in the clouds of heaven, there will be no more “do-overs.” The chasm between salvation and damnation is fixed and impassable. Back in Isaiah chapter 26 we find this warning:

“Though You [God] extend grace to the wicked and are kind to them, they never seem to learn how important it is to do what’s right. Even in a land where justice and righteousness are emphasized, the wicked continue doing evil and disregard Your sovereignty and rule. O Lord, they don’t seem to know that one day YOU WILL CALL THEM TO ACCOUNT. . . . Let them know that their sins will bring on them the eternal fires of extinction.”

So friend, borrowing from the old soap opera title, we have “One Life to Live.” One lifetime of growing . . . and falling . . . and forgiveness . . . and second chances. But at the end of that life, either at the cemetery or the judgment bar of God, by then we must have made our decision.

And this Father Abraham tells us that there absolutely will not be a messenger from beyond the grave, from the other side. There’s one place where we have to get our warnings, and that’s from the Word of God. In The Message paraphrase, this rich man begs:

“Send [Lazarus] to the house of my father where I have five brothers, so he can tell them the score and warn them so they won’t end up in this place of torment.”

And let’s get Abraham’s answer from the wonderful Living Bible paraphrase. This is so crucial to notice:
“But Abraham said, ‘The Scriptures have warned them again and again. Your brothers can read them anytime they want to.’ The rich man replied, ‘No, Father Abraham, THEY WON’T BOTHER TO READ THEM.’”

There you have it, friend. For my money, this is what the story is about. One chance. No “do-overs.” We get one chance to choose heaven. And we find out about it, about heaven’s plan, through one Book. And it’s a Book we have to bother to read.

 

 

Go back to the top